
Writing
the Academic Book Review
I no longer teach this course regularly. This
workshop aids students in actually writing and publishing
a book review for a peer-reviewed journal. At the first
session, students receive instruction on why graduate students
should (or should not) write book reviews, how to choose
a book for review, how to chose a journal for submission,
how to read a book for review, how to plan and structure
a book review, and five common pitfalls of reviewing. Students
also form small groups to discuss the book each plans to
review.At the second meeting, students bring a draft of
their book review for exchange and feedback. At the third
meeting, students arrive with a final version of their essay
to submit to an editor for publication.
This workshop is sometimes
offered by a particular journal with the editors serving
on a panel the first night to provide students with specific
advice for submitting reviews to their journal. I did such
a workshop for Aztlán: A Journal of Chicano
Studies, with the editors Chon A. Noriega and Alicia Gaspar
de Alba.
To
read the handout, click on Writing
the Academic Book Review, which includes information
on how to chose a book to review, chose a journal to submit
the review, read the book, make an outline and plan, write
the reivew, and avoid common pitfalls.
Syllabus
Session 1, Week 1
Introduction
to book reviewing
Selecting
an appropriate book to review
Five
essential elements of any book review
Typical
errors graduate student reviewers make
Session 2, Week 10
Assignment:
First draft due
Discussion
of the writing process and challenges
Exchanging
and critiquing first drafts
Some
instructions on revising
Session 3, Week 16
Assignment: Final
draft due
Discussion
of the writing process and challenges
Working
with editors and the publication process
Refreshments